What Is a Demand Letter in a New York Personal Injury Case—and Why It Matters

November 17, 2025

What Is a Demand Letter in a New York Personal Injury Case—and Why It Matters

When you’ve been injured in an accident caused by someone else’s negligence, the legal process often begins long before a lawsuit is filed. One of the most important early steps in a New York personal injury case is the demand letter. This document sets the stage for negotiation, settlement, and potentially the entire outcome of your case.


What Is a Demand Letter?


A demand letter is a formal written communication sent by the injured party (or their attorney) to the at-fault party or their insurance company. It outlines:


  • The details of the accident and how it occurred.
  • The injuries sustained and the medical treatment required.
  • The financial losses and emotional suffering experienced.
  • The amount of compensation being requested.


This letter provides the insurance company with all the information it needs to evaluate the claim. It’s not just a request—it’s a persuasive, evidence-based summary designed to show why the victim deserves fair compensation.


Why the Demand Letter Matters


In New York, the demand letter can significantly influence whether a case settles quickly or proceeds to litigation. A well-prepared letter

can:


  • Encourage settlement: When backed by strong documentation, it often leads to negotiations that resolve the claim without going to court.
  • Set the tone: It frames your position clearly and demonstrates your commitment to pursuing full compensation.
  • Document your claim: It creates a clear, dated record of your injuries, expenses, and requests, which can be valuable evidence if the case proceeds further.


What Should Be Included


A strong demand letter in a personal injury case typically includes:


  • Police reports, photos, or witness statements supporting fault.
  • Medical records and bills showing injury severity and costs.
  • Proof of lost wages and other damages.
  • A clear calculation of the total amount sought for compensation.


How a New York Personal Injury Attorney Can Help


Drafting an effective demand letter requires legal knowledge, negotiation strategy, and careful documentation. At Law Offices of Jonathan Van Dina, PLLC, we can provide legal assistance to the Hicksville public by preparing comprehensive demand letters, negotiating with insurance companies, and pursuing fair settlements for injured clients.

Dark escalators with bright steps, descending into a dimly lit area.
October 14, 2025
Injured in an elevator or escalator accident in New York? Learn who may be liable and how to pursue compensation. The Law Offices of Jonathan Van Dina, PLLC helps Hicksville residents protect their rights.
Stack of overflowing file folders.
September 29, 2025
Learn how long you have to file a personal injury lawsuit in New York. The Law Offices of Jonathan Van Dina, PLLC helps Hicksville residents understand filing deadlines and protect their rights.
Statue of Lady Justice on desk with hands and documents.
August 20, 2025
Learn who can file a wrongful death lawsuit in New York and what damages may be recovered. The Law Offices of Jonathan Van Dina, PLLC helps Nassau County families seek justice.
A row of cars are driving down a city street at night.
July 15, 2025
Dashcam footage can be critical after a car accident in New York. Learn how it can support your injury claim and how the Law Offices of Jonathan Van Dina, PLLC helps Hicksville drivers use it to pursue compensation.
A lot of cars are driving down a highway at sunset.
June 18, 2025
Injured by an uninsured driver in New York? Learn how no-fault and uninsured motorist coverage works—and how Law Offices of Jonathan Van Dina, PLLC helps Hicksville residents pursue compensation.
A man is riding a red motorcycle down a road.
May 12, 2025
Motorcycle accident claims in New York differ from car crashes due to no-fault insurance exclusions and unique legal challenges. Learn how the Law Offices of Jonathan Van Dina, PLLC helps injured Nassau County riders pursue compensation.
A scale of justice and a judge 's gavel are on a wooden table.
May 1, 2025
Learn what evidence is essential to winning a personal injury case in Nassau County, NY. Discover how the Law Offices of Jonathan Van Dina, PLLC can help you gather proof and fight for fair compensation.
A yellow sign that says caution wet floor cleaning in progress
March 20, 2025
Learn when a property owner may be liable for slip and fall injuries in New York. The Law Offices of Jonathan Van Dina, PLLC helps Hicksville residents seek fair compensation.
February 24, 2025
Injured in a store in New York? Learn about premises liability and your legal rights. Law Offices of Jonathan Van Dina, PLLC helps Hicksville residents seek compensation for store-related injuries. Contact us today.
A close up of a motorcycle driving down a road.
December 30, 2024
Discover how New York’s helmet requirements affect personal injury claims for motorcycle accidents. Learn how helmet use can influence your right to compensation and the importance of proper legal guidance from the Law Offices of Jonathan Van Dina in New York.